Starring: Simon Pegg, Nick Frost, Seth Rogen, Jason Bateman, Kristen Wiig, Bill Hader
So finally, the long awaited third film from Pegg and Frost hit our screens! But was it worth the wait?
Erm...kind of.
Clive and Graeme are two English nerds who travel to San Diego for Comic Con, then plan to take a road trip through the U.S.A’s notorious alien hotspots (Area 51, Roswell etc). However, they get a little sidetracked when an alien named Paul crashes (literally) into their lives, and more importantly their Winnebago. Paul has been living on earth for years, and is the American government’s best kept secret. However, now that they’ve learnt all they can from him (alive), they want to cut out his brain and study his cells for scientific research. Paul has managed to escape from the government, and is on the run.
Look – I love Spaced. Shaun of the Dead is a slice of fried gold. Hot Fuzz will never make me want to “jog on”.
But Paul was just missing something.
It had some brilliant nods to sci-fi classics. Pegg and Frost were on form. It had Bill Hader, Seth Rogen and Kristen Wiig in it. Greg Mottola is a great director. It should have been fucking hilarious. Instead, it ended up being mildly hilarious with a smattering of anti-climax. Don’t get me wrong, it’s a good film. It’s just not a great film. There’ll be no cult following. Sadly, I think Paul will likely be forgotten in a few years, while Shaun of the Dead and Spaced are still paid a steady (and deserving) homage by a plethora of fans.
Paul almost has it all – car chases, gun fights, Nick Frost pissing himself – except the directorial presence of the amazing Edgar Wright. I’m not being some sucky fanboy and immediately dismissing the film because it wasn’t directed by him – I went to the cinema fully expecting it to be brilliant. I thought Pegg and Frost would be able to shine quite aptly on their own. But something was just off – at times the comedic timing didn’t quite work. They relied too heavily on making the humour generic and easy to understand.
That’s not what Pegg and Frost’s work is about. It’s usually geek-culture and it’s usually bloody fantastic. Nothing against any Americans reading, but it felt more geared towards an American audience than a British one. I don’t think I could pick out a joke from Paul that showcased the quintessentially British humour of Spaced.
I went in there expecting Shaun of the Dead and came out feeling like I’d watched Saturday Night Live. Sure, it’s still funny, but it’s clichéd and it’s too simple.
Having said that, it’s the best comedy I’ve seen in a while. It is a quality film – don’t let me put you off. Just don’t expect it to be anything like their previous films. Hot Fuzz sometimes gets a bad rap but what other film can you watch where an old lady with a shotgun gets dropkicked in the face?* Likewise, what other zombie film have you watched where the protagonists beat up a zombie with pool cues to Don’t Stop Me Now?
Paul has its moments, but unlike its predecessors they are sparser, stupider, and less engaging. You will enjoy the film, no doubt about that. But don’t go in with any illusions. If you’re a sci-fi nerd I’m sure you’ll happily sit there having a little nerdgasm, but for me it just fell a little short of the mark.
*If you do know of any other films where little old ladies get drop-kicked in the face, please do let me know as I need to see them!
